Thursday, June 8, 2023

Attorney General James Sues Militant Anti-Abortion Group for Invading Clinics and Blocking Access to Reproductive Health Care

 

Red Rose Rescue Violated Clinic Access Laws and Trespassed at Abortion Clinics on Long Island and in Westchester 

Lawsuit Seeks to Prohibit Red Rose Rescue from Coming Within 30 Feet Any Reproductive Health Care Facility in New York State

 New York Attorney General Letitia James today filed a lawsuit against members of Red Rose Rescue, an anti-abortion extremist group, for invading reproductive health care clinics, threatening staff and clinicians, and terrorizing patients. Red Rose Rescue and its members — including Christopher “Fidelis” Moscinski, Matthew Connolly, William Goodman, Laura Gies, and John Hinshaw — have repeatedly trespassed at abortion clinics and physically blocked access to reproductive health care services in an effort to stop clinics from operating. Red Rose Rescue members have interfered with clinics in Nassau and Westchester Counties by lying to clinicians in order to gain access to the facilities under false pretenses, physically occupying waiting rooms and refusing to leave, and barricading entrances. At each of the New York clinics, multiple patients’ appointments were delayed or missed due to Red Rose Rescue’s actions.

Obstructing or interfering with access to reproductive health care clinics, including abortion clinics, is illegal under the United States Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (FACE Act) and the New York State Clinic Access Act. In the lawsuit filed today, Attorney General James seeks to prohibit Red Rose Rescue members from coming within 30 feet of any reproductive health care facility in New York state, in addition to civil penalties and damages.

“Red Rose Rescue has made it their mission to terrorize reproductive health care providers and the patients they serve,” said Attorney General James. “Only we have the right to make decisions about our own bodies — not anti-choice legislators, and not bigoted zealots. We will not allow Red Rose Rescue to harass and harangue New Yorkers with their outrageous militant tactics. Make no mistake: abortion is health care, and as New York’s Attorney General, I will continue to protect and defend everyone’s legal right to safely access health care.”

Red Rose Rescue is a radical anti-abortion group whose members seek to prevent abortions by trespassing into private medical facilities and clinics and refusing to leave until they are physically removed by law enforcement. Despite multiple convictions in New York and across the country, Red Rose Rescue continues to repeat their hateful, disruptive, and criminal misconduct, terrorizing reproductive health care providers and patients. In the past two years, Red Rose Rescue has delayed and interfered with the provision of reproductive health care services at three clinics in New York.

All Women’s Care in Manhasset, Nassau County
On April 24, 2021, Moscinski, Gies, Hinshaw, and members of Red Rose Rescue invaded All Women’s Care, a reproductive health services clinic. One member of the group pretended to be a patient seeking care in order to infiltrate the clinic. After checking in for her appointment, she went to a side entrance and opened it to let in additional members of Red Rose Rescue, who invaded the waiting room and lay on the ground screaming that they would not leave. When Moscinski entered, he was carrying a black duffle bag, which staff and patients feared held weapons. He pulled out his friar’s robes and changed in the waiting room. Clinic staff, concerned about safety, directed patients to leave and take cover in their cars. Red Rose Rescue disrupted operations at the clinic for two hours. When threatened with arrest, they went limp and fell to the ground, forcing police to carry them out of the clinic. On April 17, 2023, Hinshaw was sentenced to 30 days in jail and three years’ probation for criminal trespass and obstructing the police. Gies and Moscinski are currently serving jail sentences in Michigan and will be sentenced on June 30, 2023.

All Women’s Health in White Plains, Westchester County
On November 27, 2021, Moscinski, Goodman, Connolly, and members of Red Rose Rescue invaded All Women’s Health and Medical Services, a private reproductive health clinic. One member pretended to be a patient seeking an abortion and once admitted to the clinic, held the door open for other Red Rose Rescue members to rush inside, where they occupied the waiting room and threatened to stay until the facility stopped performing abortions, forcing patients to hide out in the hallways. The occupation lasted for two hours before they were carried out. On August 2, 2022, Moscinski, Goodman, and Connolly were each sentenced to three months in jail for criminal trespass.

Planned Parenthood in Hempstead, Nassau County
On July 7, 2022, Moscinski placed six industrial locks and chains on the front gates of a Planned Parenthood clinic, blocking the driveway into the parking lot and pedestrian access gates so that staff and patients could not enter. Neither the police nor the fire department could cut the locks with manual tools and ultimately resorted to a battery-operated saw. When the locks were finally removed, Moscinski laid down in the driveway to prevent cars from entering the facility and had to be physically removed and carried out by multiple police officers. Moscinski was convicted of criminal violation of the FACE Act and is scheduled to be sentenced on June 27, 2023.

With this lawsuit, Attorney General James seeks to protect New York reproductive health care facilities and their patients by prohibiting Red Rose Rescue, Moscinski, Connolly, Goodman, Gies, Hinshaw, and their associates from knowingly coming within 30 feet of any clinic in the state. Attorney General James is also seeking civil penalties and damages to be determined by the court.

This lawsuit is the latest action Attorney General James has taken to defend abortion access in New York and across the country. Following the Supreme Court’s decision to end Roe v. Wade, Attorney General James launched a pro bono legal hotline to provide legal support to patients and health care providers nationwide. Attorney General James has repeatedly led multi-state coalitions in submitting amicus briefs to combat efforts to roll back abortion rights, and to support protecting Americans’ access to safe, legal abortions. During former President Trump’s Administration, Attorney General James challenged attempts to restrict access to reproductive healthcare services, such as the Trump administration's Title X rule and submitted testimony urging passage of the Women’s Health Protection Act. Attorney General James has helped lead coalitions of attorneys general to defend abortion access in states including ArizonaIdahoIndianaMississippi, and Texas. Attorney General James has supported state legislation to provide funds to abortion providers in New York and called for an amendment to the state constitution to ensure the right to an abortion.

Most recently, Attorney General James co-led a multistate coalition in filing an amicus brief in Texas v. Becerra, supporting the Biden Administration’s U.S. Department of Health and Human Service’s defense of access to emergency abortion careLast month, Attorney General James led two separate multistate coalitions in filing two amicus briefs in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit arguing that separate decisions issued by the same district court judge in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas would harm access to mifepristone and threaten privacy protections over adolescents’ reproductive health care decisions.

“Planned Parenthood of Greater New York applauds New York Attorney General Letitia James for taking a stand against protestors outside our health centers that harass, threaten, and intimidate patients seeking health care,” said Dipal Shah, Executive Director and Chief External Affairs Officer, Planned Parenthood of Greater New York Action Fund. “Everyone deserves the ability to access the care they need without threat or fear. With this action, the Attorney General is standing up for New Yorkers’ right to access care with dignity. PPGNY is committed to fostering a safe environment that honors everyone’s right to access the full range of sexual and reproductive health care  which will always include abortion services. We are proud to continue to work with the Attorney General and lawmakers on long-term solutions to maintain safe and dignified access to our health centers, no matter what.”

Governor Hochul Updates New Yorkers on Dangerous Air Quality

Governor Hochul updates New Yorkers on air quality. 

Team of Seven Forest Rangers Head to Quebec; Ranger Crew Boss Deployed to Nova Scotia Last Week

Smoke From Raging Wildfires Continues to Trigger Air Quality Health Advisories

New Air Quality Safety Protocols Are Effective Immediately for All Horse Racing in New York

Governor Hochul: "This is an extraordinary event. It's unprecedented - in terms of the source of the air contaminants that we're experiencing right now - that we are now talking about the fact that there still remains poor air quality across the State of New York. [...] We are still seeing [air quality in] every place [in New York State] is unhealthy except for the Adirondacks."

Hochul: "I don't think there's a single person who hasn't felt something, something different. You know, more frequent coughing and just the tightness in the throat and watering of the eyes. And those are for people who are healthy. For those who have health conditions underlying already, it's a real challenge for them."

 The National Weather Service is here. We have our Mesonet, so we have our meteorologists able to monitor in real time what is happening with the weather. And the weather has certainly taken a front row position in terms of our attention these days.  

I just want to take a moment to, first of all, acknowledge my extraordinary team with me. We have our Commissioner of Emergency Services, Jackie Bray. We have our Commissioner of Health, Dr. McDonald. We have Commissioner Seggos, our Commissioner of DEC, and they are on this nonstop because this continues to be a public health crisis.  

And we want to make sure that we are deploying all of our resources and help to anybody where we can, and the most important thing is information. The most important thing we can do is give people real time information and let them know what they can be doing to protect the health of themselves and their families. So, we've been acknowledging the fact that even today, after six days of notifications coming out from DEC, that people, you know, are aware that this is happening, that you know, this is an extraordinary event. It's unprecedented — in terms of the source of the air contaminants that we're experiencing right now — that we are now talking about the fact that there still remains poor air quality across the State of New York.  

And I just want to give an update from our update yesterday. We are still seeing every place is unhealthy except for the Adirondacks. Now, that might be a nice promotion for the Adirondacks. That is the only place with clean air in the state right now. We're seeing unhealthy air quality levels on Long Island, New York, Eastern Lake, Ontario, Central New York, Western New York. 

And then we also have categories of healthy for sensitive individuals. There's two different categories: unhealthy for everybody, unhealthy for people with sensitivities. That would be children, senior citizens, people with respiratory challenges. That'd be the upper and lower Hudson Valleys. 

We saw yesterday some very disturbing numbers. In New York City, they've come down from the 400 level, but we should never get complacent and think that the 200 Air Quality Index is satisfactory. But right now, we're experiencing 209 in Brooklyn, 207 in Queens and 191 in the Bronx. And again, normal is 50. Actually, quite often in the State of New York, we have pristine air. It's normally about 35. You know, frequently it's 35, normal is 50. So, we look to see weather improving over a few days. We're having the rain right now.

Apparently, the particles are attached to the rain, and they come down, but it does have a chance to cleanse them. We can have more explanation on that from Jackie Bray, but we still have spikes, individual spikes of over 400 in some regions. And the message is, "This is not over." You know, we might get a little respite, but I don't want people to let down their guard and to become complacent about this because we have to be prepared for the winds to shift.

This is the unknown. We're tracking the large plume that is originating from primarily Nova Scotia, Eastern - you know, and also Quebec. But also, you know, knowing that this is going to continue to have a negative impact on our health. I don't think there's a single person who hasn't felt something, something different. You know, more frequent coughing and just the tightness in the throat and watering of the eyes. And those are for people who are healthy. For those who have health conditions underlying already, it's a real challenge for them. 

And so we want to make sure that we're getting in touch with people. There are people in vulnerable communities, people who may not be checking their phone every couple of minutes for updates. They may not be seeing the news, and these are the people we're trying to reach out to. 

We want to make sure that people stay indoors. Yesterday, we asked schools and child care centers to cancel or postpone outdoor school activities. Again, let's talk about the school environment. It is very safe in our school buildings, particularly since during the pandemic, we used federal dollars and were aggressively getting new filters in our schools, in our child care centers. So they are much safer than children playing outside. We've been asked often, "Should we be canceling schools?" If that means the kids are going to be outside, absolutely not. Just after school activities that are outdoor, we're talking about. 

We're also having employers encourage them to make sure their own employees are taking precautions. Our own state workforce. We are tracking the air quality regularly, adjusting work assignments and asking our commissioners to be very attuned to what's going on in the particular region they are. 

I will also say, this was brought up yesterday, this is our old friend — one you never want to see again, perhaps. But this mask can make a difference, not just outdoor, although I did see someone outside running on my way here wearing one of these masks. At least he was wearing a mask. But even indoors, if you have a situation where you don't have air conditioning, you have a situation where you're not feeling good inside, continue to put this on. This will make a big difference for people.

We are distributing these, we did these during the morning rush this morning in New York City. We have them at state parks, MTA stations, Javits Center, bus terminals. So we're trying to be as, you know, open-minded to different opportunities to get these out to people, encouraging local governments. We did a Zoom call last night with all the county executives and the mayors across the state letting them know that we have resources, we have storage depots where we have these available to them as well. 

So I wanted to also announce that we are announcing that we are sending Forest Rangers to Canada, larger scale operations. I can have Commissioner Seggos talk about that, but this is after I spoke to the Consul General yesterday to just touch base in Canada, see how they're doing, and he was meeting with the Prime Minister. We offered more assistance — we had offered previously — but they're now taking us up on it. So, we're sending our first firefighters who are joining individuals from New Hampshire and Maine as well. They'll be departing from the Saratoga Fire Department on Friday and traveling to Quebec. They've asked for seven people over the next two weeks. We can certainly change those numbers at their request. I also noted that President Biden is also sending firefighters. This is how we can deal with this, helping Canada get to these really remote areas. 

This is what the Consul General told me. He says, "These are such remote areas, they're almost impossible to access, but containment's important to us. We want to get these under control." So, I'm really proud that we're going to have New York citizens up there trying to battle these fires to help Canada, but also the collateral damage, which is that the State of New York has been really hard hit by inferior air quality, unsatisfactory air quality. 

I know a lot of people are looking forward to the Belmont Stakes this weekend, so let me give a report on that. We have instituted enhanced measures to protect the horses and the riders and the spectators. Yesterday we decided, at my direction, the Gaming Commission directed all tracks to stop workouts and trainings yesterday. That will continue through today. 

And this morning, the measures we are going to implement: if the air quality exceeds 200 at the facility, at any facility, there will be no racing. That's going to be canceled, if the air quality is above 200. If the air quality is 150 to 200, only horses that pass an additional pre-race vet examination will be permitted to race and we will be closely monitoring this because this is a national phenomenon. People come from all over the country. It's huge for the local economy. And so, we hopefully can get this going, but there's no assurance of what the weather's going to be, so it's going to be a last-minute decision, I'm sure.  

We are still having significant delays at our airports, LaGuardia in particular. Downstate airports are definitely affected, but the National Weather Service predicts that conditions should start to improve and we're monitoring all the conditions that airports regularly. Here's my message: "This is the new reality we're dealing with."

I know a lot of people are stressed out after what happened during the pandemic. I want people to know this is a very different circumstance. We believe it will be short term, not long term. Decisions will have to be made to keep people indoors. We're not making those decisions. This is personal, but we are taking climate change so seriously here in the State of New York, always have been. 

And I've said before, we're the first generation to really feel the effects of climate change and the last one to be able to do anything meaningful about it. So that is why we're going to continue our fight against climate change. And you think about even the Clean Air Act, which we have, the reason we have a Clean Air Act enacted back in 1970, was the tremendous loss of life when we had the smog event in New York City back in 1966 and almost 170 people lost their lives because of the air quality at the time. 

So we're living in an era of extreme weather, statement of fact, and we're going to continue doing what we can to help do our part. We're doing our best in New York. We also need other states and the international community to join this fight as well, because I don't know what more evidence they need that we are in a crisis with our climate right now. Let's talk about what New Yorkers can do.

I think about how to prepare. We do a lot of notices when it comes to major snow events, what people need to be doing to take precautions. But I think it's as simple as this. You don't need a snow shovel. You need to keep the masks in your house, and you need to keep your phone handy and there is information on your phone in real time.

We can get you the numbers, you can look up easily just on your weather app. You can go to our sites, but you can also just go to the weather map. Look for that number. That number appears on your app. It'll tell you what is going on. Right now we're at about 191, I believe, in Albany, at least it was a little bit earlier today.

So, keep an eye on that and that should gauge your family activities. You should make decisions based on those numbers and really restrict yourself until you see those numbers starting to get into a safer zone. And it's all very clear for people. But again, not everybody has a phone. They're not watching all day. There are residents out there who need our help. 

And similar to a snowstorm. Check on your neighbors. Check on senior citizens who may not be on a cell phone, may not be watching the news, and these are some of the most vulnerable people we have in our state. So, this is another opportunity to be a good neighbor, to check in on people.

And also in your own home and in your car, you can turn on the air conditioning, but be aware. That you need to have the recirculate button on in your car and in your home, especially if you're using in your home, one of the window air conditioners, because otherwise you're drawing in outdoor air right into your home and that is dangerous.

Turn on the recirculating the air so it stays internally and make sure that your filters are clean. A lot of people don't replace them very much. They lose their effectiveness if you don't replace the filters and clean them regularly. So that's what's important. Get out to everybody. For the meantime, really the best thing to do is just stay indoors.

That way, you won't have unintended health effects, you won't have the discomfort of having the smoke fill your lungs. And we're asked often about it. Are we seeing an increase in people going to emergency rooms? Are we seeing the health effects? It is still early. This has only been in full force in a very detrimental, dangerous way for the last few days.

And it does take some time, but we have seen, Dr. McDonald is monitoring, we're not seeing a spike in people going to emergency rooms, but there are a couple hospitals particularly in New York City, that are reporting more people stopping in. So I would like to ask Commissioner Basil Seggos to talk a little bit more about the Mesonet, how we're doing our real-time monitoring of information, and then we'll be happy to give a tour of that afterwards so everybody knows exactly how we're getting our information and making sure it gets out to the public as soon as possible.