Independent Democratic Conference proposes Vehicle Ramming Prevention Act in response to Lower Manhattan Attack

New report details the increase in the use of vehicles to carry out attacks

Senators Jeff Klein, Jesse Hamilton, and David Carlucci, following the Halloween terrorist attack in Lower Manhattan on Wednesday announced new legislation to prevent further vehicular style attacks. The new proposal, the Vehicle Ramming Prevention Act, consists of four proposals to limit the potential for future attacks of this style.

“New Yorkers were fearless in the face of terror, but they also know that we must always remain vigilant and find ways to safeguard the public against terrorists. This legislation will help commercial and truck rental companies report suspicious behavior, fortify their safety plans and know what to look out for if a person strays from that plan. We also want to invest in infrastructure protections for New York City, and beyond, to keep our citizens safe,” said Senator Klein.

“Protecting New Yorkers requires the vigilance of our first responders, our communities, and all of us as policy makers. The measures we advance today uphold our responsibility to remain vigilant and ensure those plotting to do us harm fail,” said Senator Hamilton.

“New York must be proactive to safeguard the lives of our residents from terrorist acts,” said Senator Carlucci

Under the Vehicle Ramming Prevention Act, the Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services would create a hotline for rental companies to report suspicious rental activity. It would also require the division to create a countermeasure guidance document so that employees of rental companies are aware of questions and activity that could be reason for concern. The guidelines would be required to be posted in an area frequently visited by employees.

The proposal also requires rental companies and commercial truck companies to develop vehicle ramming prevention plans, based off the countermeasures developed by the TSA and file them with the Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services.

Finally, the Independent Democratic Conference will advocate for funding in the budget to be made available for cities to develop and build infrastructure around pedestrian areas that may be vulnerable to vehicle-ramming attacks.

The report found a stark increase in the number of attacks using a vehicle as a weapon since 2013. Between 2014 and April 2017 terrorists have carried out 17 known vehicle ramming attacks worldwide,  resulting in 173 fatalities and 667 injuries.

Attacks of this nature have risen since a 2010 publication by al-Qaeda encouraged their use, followed by additional promotion in a 2014 video produced by ISIS.

Following the attack on October 31, the NYPD concluded that the incident was in line with the directions that have been promoted by terrorist organizations.

OFFICE OF THE MAYOR THE CITY OF NEW YORK - FACT SHEET: THE TRUTH BEHIND THE GOP’S TAX PLAN

Last week, Congressional Republicans unveiled the “Tax Cuts and Jobs Act” – the first, major overhaul of American tax policy in decades. Despite promises to present a plan that would alleviate the financial stress felt by middle class families nationwide, the plan is nothing more than a giveaway to businesses and the wealthiest Americans.

The below details the bill’s effect on New Yorkers. 

The Biggest Losers

In New York City, 3.9 million families file federal income taxes. Of those, under this plan, 760,000 families – the majority of whom are making less than $75,000 annually – would see an increase averaging almost $5,000 next year. That’s an additional $3.7 billion the federal government will claim from these New Yorkers. 

Corporate America Wins, Working Class Families Lose

The biggest reasons why New Yorkers will see an increase in their taxes come next April are the changes to the personal exemption and the limiting of the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction. By eliminating the personal exemption and replacing it with changes to standard deductions and with tax credits that are ultimately less valuable and will be partially repealed in 2023, the federal government is essentially penalizing New Yorkers who have chosen to have a larger family. A married couple, filing jointly, with an income of $100,000 and four dependents (two children, two college-age), and $31,000 in itemized deductions would see taxes increase by $897 (+24%).

Further, the Republican bill eliminates the deduction for state and local income tax – a deduction as old as the federal income tax itself, designed to protect from double taxation – and caps the property tax deduction at $10,000.  That means taxes on some homeowners will increase while the values of their homes decrease. The 617,000 filers who currently take the property tax deduction will see a net tax increase of $2.0 billion.

SALT alone is worth $7.7 billion to New Yorkers. For example, a married couple, filing jointly, with income of $200,000, one non-child dependent, and $37,500 in itemized deductions (of which $30,000 is SALT), would see their taxes increase by $970. 

And while our middle class families struggle to pay taxes on the same income twice, the deduction remains fully intact for businesses.

The benefits in this bill are so unevenly weighted, the only taxpayers guaranteed a massive tax cut are businesses and large estates. Under this plan, business income receives a $1 trillion tax cut over ten years, adding to the Country’s projected $10.1 trillion deficit. For New Yorkers, you can safely assume these corporate handouts will eventually lead the White House and the bill’s authors to slash Medicaid, public safety and the affordable housing programs we desperately need.

Undermining Working Families

The elimination of several deductions will be immediately felt by New Yorkers in every borough. As a result of this plan:

• People with college debt – 250,000 filers in NYC alone – will no longer be able to deduct that interest from their federal income taxes. For example, a single filer with an income of $42,000, itemized deductions of $12,000, and $2,500 in student loan interest deduction, would see her taxes go up by $222 (+7%).
• New Yorkers struggling with exorbitant medical expenses will now pay more for necessary care. For example, a married couple filing jointly with $60,000 in income and $24,500 in itemized deductions (of which $18,000 is medical expenses) would see their taxes increase by $497 (+32%).
• Hardworking teachers using their own money on school supplies will no longer be able to deduct their expenses.

Additionally, beginning in 2023, working parents would no longer be able to exclude any child care expenses from their income. In New York City, at least 30,000 families currently take advantage of the exclusion, helping them plan daycare while they’re at work.

Unaffordable Housing

 

Housing is the number-one expense for New Yorkers. And more than half of households here spend more on rent than they can afford. Under this Administration, we launched the most ambitious affordable housing plan in the city’s history and are building and protecting affordable homes at an unprecedented rate. This tax plan threatens to pull New York City in the opposite direction.

By eliminating private activity bonds – the kind of tax exempt bonds our Housing Development Corporation and other housing finance agencies issue to fund new affordable apartments – we and cities across the country lose one of the principal building blocks of affordable housing. It doesn’t stop there, either. The loss also impacts the Low Income Housing Tax Credit, one of the largest federal affordable housing financing mechanisms. About half of the program would be effectively eliminated by repealing private activity bonds.

Taken together, this bill as written, threatens $2.6 billion annually, which would jeopardize thousands of homes financed each year for working families, veterans and seniors.

This doesn’t even account for the fact that when corporate and business taxes decrease, there will be less demand for tax credits, which means we can anticipate an even greater impact on the cost of building new affordable homes.

Stifling Innovation and Job Creation

Private activity bonds are not only used for affordable apartments, they’re also a tool that many hospitals, schools and other nonprofits use to finance projects and deliver services.  Through the Build NYC program, this Administration has issued more than $3 billion in tax exempt bonds to support more than 20,000 jobs at dozens of New York City nonprofit organizations. The future of this work is at risk without this bond.

The bill also eliminates New Markets Tax Credits and Historic Tax Credits, effective and cost-efficient financing tools, which generate millions in private investment, create thousands of jobs and strengthen traditionally underserved neighborhoods.  At The Brooklyn Navy Yard, four recent projects--the Green Manufacturing Center, Building 77, B Amsterdam and Sands Street-- are using these programs to leverage $348 million in total investment and create more than 5,000 jobs.

MAYOR DE BLASIO AND KIVA ANNOUNCE FIRST-OF-ITS-KIND CROWDFUNDING PROGRAM FOR WOMEN ENTREPRENEURS

City pledges up to $1,000 in zero-interest loans for women launching crowdfunding campaigns to start or grow their businesses; City contribution will facilitate $3 million in loans and 500 new businesses in three years

  Mayor Bill de Blasio and the not-for-profit crowdfunding platform Kiva.org launched WE Fund: Crowd, a first-of-its-kind City-led crowdfunding program to help women entrepreneurs access affordable capital and start businesses in New York City. Through Kiva, women entrepreneurs can apply for crowdfunded loans of up to $10,000 and the City will contribute the first 10% of their loan request. The program is designed to reach at least 500 businesses over three years.  

“Leveling the playing field for women entrepreneurs will help grow and diversify our economy, and strengthen our families and neighborhoods,” Mayor Bill de Blasio said. “With Kiva, we will help launch small businesses that might otherwise never get off the ground.” 

“Connecting women entrepreneurs directly to investors gives them access to seed money they need to open stores, restaurants and fashion companies in neighborhoods across New York City. As we continue to focus on stabilizing communities, growing jobs and supporting women in business, this collaboration with Kiva.org is simple and smart,” Alicia Glen, Deputy Mayor for Housing and Economic Development said.

“This joint initiative aims to drive social impact as well as provide crowdfunded capital to women who are traditionally denied loans,” said Jonny Price, Senior Director of Kiva U.S. “At a national level, if women were to receive a proportional amount of traditional small business loans, lending to women would increase almost sevenfold. This partnership is so important it can go a long way in demonstrating a path forward for entrepreneurial women across the country.”

WE Fund: Crowd helps address the gender entrepreneurship gap:

· Seventy percent of women entrepreneurs in New York City cite access to capital as a major challenge as they launch and grow companies. 

·  While approximately half of women entrepreneurs in New York City seek less than $10,000 when launching a business, traditional financial products are often unavailable in small amounts and non-traditional financial products typically come with high interest rates.

Entrepreneurs interested in the program should visit we.nyc.

  

How WE Fund: Crowd works:

·  The City will contribute the first 10% of an entrepreneur’s crowdfunding goal when they launch their campaign.

· This loan from the City will be confirmed when the entrepreneur meets their full fundraising goal.

· The City’s contribution is capped at $1,000 per campaign and includes no-interest repayment terms for up to 42 months.

· In total, the City’s commitment will facilitate more than $3 million in loans.

· Lenders: Visitors to www.Kiva.org can choose the woman entrepreneur they want to help crowdfund with a loan of $25 or more. As the entrepreneur repays, lenders can relend to another person or withdraw their money and put it back in their pocket. Neither lenders nor Kiva make any money from the loans facilitated. The City will provide the first 10% of the loan to help the entrepreneur reach her crowdfunding goal.

· Borrowers: Kiva’s loans are available up to $10,000 and are designed to reach women-owned small businesses locked out of traditional lending. Loans are offered at 0% interest, no fees, no minimum credit score, collateral, or minimum years of operation. Ninety-five percent of loan requests are fully fundraised, which is rare among crowdfunding sites. 

This partnership with New York City is the first time that Kiva has worked on a government-supported crowdfunding initiative to provide seed money specifically for women entrepreneurs.

Founded in 2005, Kiva is an international nonprofit with a mission to connect people through lending to alleviate poverty and expand economic opportunity. Kiva has connected 2.5 million entrepreneurs in 83 countries with over $1 billion in loans crowdfunded by 2 million individuals.

WE Fund: Crowd is also partnering with Kickstarter, Indiegogo, GoFundMe, and CrowdCrux to create digital tools to increase women’s participation and success in crowdfunding campaigns.

Those interested may also register for the WE NYC: Show Me the Money conference on November 21st at NYU’s Kimmel Center. The program will cover an array of topics related to business finance, including crowdfunding and other accessible financing options.

WE Fund: Crowd is part of WE NYC, a women’s entrepreneurship initiative launched by the City’s Department of Small Business Services in 2015. WE NYC connects women to mentoring, expert advice and customized business and leadership courses to help them start and grow successful businesses. WE NYC has engaged nearly 4,000 women across New York City.

“The City is invested in women entrepreneurs and today we are proving it by launching an innovative program to help more women raise the capital they need to succeed,” said Gregg Bishop, Commissioner of the City’s Department of Small Business Services. “Having the City as their first investor will help women entrepreneurs build momentum in their crowdfunding campaigns and attract additional investors.”

“I believe that WE Fund: Crowd, a first-of-its-kind City-led crowdfunding program to help women entrepreneurs access affordable capital and start businesses in New York City is an excellent program to give women a competitive edge in launching a business,” said Nunzio Del Greco, President and CEO of the Bronx Chamber of Commerce.

100 PERCENT MAYORAL PREDICTION

100 PERCENT 

By Robert Press

Election Predictions

MAYOR

  

Bill de Blasio                   62 %

Nicole Malliotakis          27 %

Bo Dietl                             7 %

Sal Albanese                     2 %

Write in/Other                 2 % 

All incumbent Bronx City Council members re-elected.

Open Seats - 

13th It will now be Councilman Mark Gjonaj     58 %

18th It will now be Councilman Ruben Diaz Sr. 79 %

Posted two hours before polls closed.
Comments will be accepted, and published if not out of order.

                                                    

Chairman Of Purported Hedge Fund Sentenced For Conspiring To Commit Securities And Wire Fraud

  Joon H. Kim, the Acting United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, announced that NICHOLAS MITSAKOS was sentenced today to 30 months in prison on charges of conspiring to commit securities fraud and wire fraud in connection with his operation of a purported hedge fund called Matrix Capital.  MITSAKOS pled guilty on May 25, 2017, and was sentenced by the Honorable Denny Chin, a judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit who was sitting by designation in the Southern District of New York.

Acting Manhattan U.S. Attorney Joon H. Kim said:  “As he previously admitted in pleading guilty, Nicholas Mitsakos spun a fake tale to investors about his miraculous track record of trading in the securities markets.  Mitsakos lured investors by claiming returns of over 66 percent for one year, never disclosing that his portfolio was an entirely ‘hypothetical’ one and that in fact, he had never entered into any real trades.”

According to the Complaint, Indictment, and statements made during court proceedings:

In or about October 2013, MITSAKOS created a purported hedge fund called Matrix Capital (“Matrix”), which claimed to be a long-short fund with a long track record of success.  In order to raise money for his fund, MITSAKOS sent marketing materials to numerous potential investors claiming that Matrix had achieved outsized returns that exceeded major indices like the S&P 500.  One newsletter sent to potential investors, for example, claimed that Matrix had achieved returns of approximately 25% in 2012, 66% in 2013, 20% in 2014, and 49% between January and October of 2015.  MITSAKOS also led potential investors to believe that these returns were based on actual securities trades by Matrix, and that Matrix had tens of millions in assets under management (“AUM”). 

MITSAKOS’s representations regarding Matrix’s performance and AUM were false.  In fact, Matrix had no track record in actually purchasing and selling securities, and, indeed, had no meaningful assets at all until receiving funds from a victim in September 2015.  Instead, the purported performance results provided to potential investors were premised on how a hypothetical portfolio would have performed had Matrix actually acquired certain securities.  No such trading actually took place and Matrix never actually owned any of the securities in the hypothetical portfolio that MITSAKOS maintained.  Even in regard to Matrix’s hypothetical investment portfolio, MITSAKOS retroactively manipulated the investments in that portfolio from time to time in order to improve dramatically its hypothetical performance. 

Based in part on these and other misrepresentations, Matrix received approximately $2 million from an investor in September 2015.  However, MITSAKOS used only a portion of that amount – about $1.2 million – to actually buy and sell securities.  Of the remaining amount, MITSAKOS spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on business expenses and personal expenses like car payments, credit cards, and his own rent.  MITSAKOS’s trading of the $1.2 million that he did invest, moreover, resulted in significant losses.

In addition to the prison sentence, MITSAKOS, 57, was sentenced to two years of supervised release.  The Court further ordered MITSAKOS to forfeit a sum of $861,163.62 and to pay restitution to victims of his offense.           

Mr. Kim praised the exceptional work of the Office’s criminal investigators, and thanked the Securities and Exchange Commission for its assistance.   

Virginia Man Pleads Guilty In Manhattan Federal Court To $100 Million Market Manipulation Scheme Involving Fitbit Stock

  Joon H. Kim, the Acting United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, announced that ROBERT WALTER MURRAY pled guilty today in Manhattan federal court to securities fraud.  In November 2016, MURRAY conducted a scheme to manipulate the market for the stock of Fitbit, Inc. (“Fitbit”) by filing a sham tender offer with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”).  The sham tender offer falsely reported that another entity had made a bid to purchase all outstanding Fitbit stock at a significant premium to the then-existing market price.  As a result, the price of Fitbit stock temporarily but significantly increased in price, allowing MURRAY to sell for a profit options that he had previously purchased.  MURRAY’s sham tender offer, moreover, resulted in a temporary inflation in Fitbit’s market capitalization of over $100 million. 

Acting U.S. Attorney Joon H. Kim said:  “As Robert Murray admitted today, he manipulated the market in Fitbit stock by making a false filing with the SEC about a tender offer.  After manipulating Fitbit's stock price and temporarily inflating its market capitalization by over $100 million, Murray sought to take a quick profit from trading in Fitbit stock.  Murray’s ill-advised and criminal attempt to game the system has ended in a federal securities fraud conviction.”  

According to the allegations in the Complaint and Indictment filed in Manhattan federal court, previous court filings, and statements made in public court proceedings:

On November 8, 2016, MURRAY, falsely purporting to be an officer at a China-based entity called ABM Capital, created an account on the SEC’s Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval (or “EDGAR”) system.  The next day, MURRAY submitted a filing on EDGAR that reported that ABM Capital had offered to purchase Fitbit for approximately $12.50 a share, a significant premium to the price of Fitbit stock at the time.  This filing was made public on November 10, 2016, and, when it was, Fitbit’s stock temporarily increased in response to the news.  While Fitbit’s stock had closed at approximately $8.55 a share on November 9, 2016, it reached a high of approximately $9.27 per share, with significantly increased trading volume, after the false tender offer filing was made public.  MURRAY’s filing, however, was entirely fictitious, and was instead meant only to increase the value of options in Fitbit stock that he had purchased just before filing the sham tender offer. 

MURRAY, moreover, took significant steps to hide his connection to the tender offer filing.  He created a separate email account to register with the SEC and to file the sham tender offer, taking care to disguise his actual IP address when accessing it. 

MURRAY, 24, of Chesapeake, Virginia, pled guilty to one count of securities fraud, which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison and a maximum fine of $5 million.  In addition, pursuant to a plea agreement with the Government, MURRAY agreed to forfeit proceeds of the offense.  MURRAY is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Katherine B. Forrest on March 9, 2018.  

The maximum potential sentence in this case is prescribed by Congress and is provided here for informational purposes only, as any sentencing of the defendant will be determined by the judge.

Mr. Kim praised the exceptional work of the Office’s criminal investigators, and thanked the United States Postal Inspection Service and the Securities and Exchange Commission for their assistance. 

DOI ARRESTS SITE SAFETY REPRESENTATIVE ON A CHARGE OF POSSESSING FRAUDULENT SAFETY CERTIFICATES

  Mark G. Peters, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Investigation (“DOI”), announced today the arrest of an individual in charge of site safety at the renovation of the New York City Housing Authority’s (“NYCHA”) Fulton Houses Community Center in Manhattan on a charge of possessing fraudulent safety training certificates. This site safety representative is required to hold a 30-hour safety certification issued by training centers approved by the United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”) and provided to construction workers who successfully complete a comprehensive safety program that provides information on OSHA compliance issues. These Site Safety representatives are responsible for the enforcement of all OSHA and government construction regulations, all NYCHA-approved site safety plans, informing workers of safety deficiencies, and maintaining a log of hazardous materials used at the work site, among other duties. Based on information provided by NYCHA, DOI investigators requested the Site Safety representative produce his OSHA safety credentials and, when he did, DOI investigators determined the certificates were fraudulent. The office of Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance, Jr., is prosecuting the case.

  DOI Commissioner Mark G. Peters said, “Individuals overseeing site safety are charged with making sure that construction sites are safe and workers are not injured. This manager, instead, relied upon false documents at a site with multiple other safety problems. Professionals who place construction workers in danger will not be tolerated and will face arrest."

  ANDREAS TSAMOS, 49, of Whitestone, N.Y., was arrested Friday, November 3, 2017, at the construction site and charged with Criminal Possession of a Forged Instrument in the Third Degree, a class A misdemeanor. Upon conviction, a class A misdemeanor is punishable by up to one year’s incarceration. TSAMOS was arraigned on Friday and released on his own recognizance. His next court date is December 5, 2017, in New York County Criminal Court.

  On Thursday, November 2, 2017, DOI investigators found numerous safety problems at NYCHA’s Fulton Houses Community Center in Manhattan, including an emergency fire exit door locked from the outside preventing workers from exiting during an emergency, a fall protection guardrail system missing where work was being done, and a scaffold was installed without any fall protection guardrail system. NYCHA ordered the contractor to correct the safety problems. City Department of Buildings’ inspectors evaluated the site Friday, November 3, 2017, and found no outstanding safety issues.

  According to the criminal complaint, also on Friday, November 3, 2017, DOI investigators asked TSAMOS, who works for Gem Quality Corporation of Brooklyn, to provide his safety credentials. The defendant 2 provided two certificates – one for a 10-hour-approved OSHA course and a second certificate for a 30-hourapproved OSHA course. Both certificates bore the same training completion date and did not indicate the course names. DOI observed that the certificates indicated the defendant took his training courses at “360Training.com”. DOI confirmed with the training company that no individual with the defendant’s name completed training courses on the date of the certificates. Additionally, the training company informed DOI that its certificates bear course names.

TSAMOS was arrested on Friday, November 3, 2017, and removed from the site. NYCHA shut down the site, which remained closed Monday, November 6, 2017, until a new site safety representative is submitted for NYCHA’s approval.

  DOI Commissioner Peters thanked NYCHA Chair and Chief Executive Officer Shola Olatoye and her staff for their cooperation and assistance in this investigation. Commissioner Peters also thanked Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance, Jr., and his staff for their assistance on this investigation. 

  The investigation was conducted by DOI’s Office of the Inspector General for NYCHA, specifically Special Investigator/Investigative Auditor David Haynes and Investigative Engineer Kris Kingpayom, under the supervision of Deputy Inspectors General Edward Bradley and Doug Schneider, Inspector General Ralph Iannuzzi, Associate Commissioner James Flaherty, Deputy Commissioner/Chief of Investigations Michael Carroll and First Deputy Commissioner Lesley Brovner. 

A criminal complaint is an accusation. A defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty.  

DOI FOLLOW-UP INVESTIGATION FINDS INSUFFICIENT INVENTORY CONTROLS OVER LARGE APPLIANCES AT NYCHA FACILITIES

  Mark G. Peters, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Investigation (“DOI”), announced that an investigation into the New York City Housing Authority’s (“NYCHA”) inventory tracking and controls of large appliances is insufficient and places inventory at risk for theft. DOI undercover investigators entered six NYCHA facilities and removed new and used refrigerators and stoves without being stopped or detected. In each of these instances, subsequent interviews with NYCHA employees revealed that managerial staff was unaware the items had been removed and did not report any appliances as missing. This investigation was a follow-up to DOI’s investigation in 2016 that exposed the problem of large appliance theft from NYCHA facilities, resulting in the arrest of a NYCHA caretaker and the recommendation for NYCHA to perform an inventory review and strengthen controls in tracking and safeguarding large appliances to prevent further theft. A copy of DOI’s Report follows this release and can also be found at the following link: http://www1.nyc.gov/site/doi/newsroom/public-reports.page/

  Commissioner Mark G. Peters said, “At a time when NYCHA faces a severe budget crisis, its failure to safeguard property simply compounds this problem. DOI undercover investigators were able to enter into NYCHA facilities and cart away large appliances, without challenge or notice.”

  DOI first informed NYCHA of breakdowns in its inventory management in July 2016, when it arrested a NYCHA caretaker for stealing three refrigerators from a NYCHA facility, and subsequently discovered that same employee had stolen additional appliances on multiple occasions, including stoves and washing machines, and sold them to an appliance store for cash. That employee pleaded guilty to Petit Larceny and resigned from NYCHA after his arrest. A copy of the press release from the July 2016 arrest can be found at the following link: http://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doi/press-releases/2016/jul/23KenyonAllen07- 22-16.pdf

  In July 2017, DOI began its follow-up investigation and surveyed 19 NYCHA developments, focusing its undercover investigations on six that readily presented security vulnerabilities. Dressed as either NYCHA employees or in plainclothes, DOI undercover investigators went to these six sites to determine whether NYCHA had strengthened its safeguards against large appliance theft, as DOI recommended a year earlier. Investigators easily removed large appliances, including refrigerators and stoves, at these six sites: Pelham Parkway Houses in the Bronx, Wald Houses and Smith Houses in Lower Manhattan, Sheepshead Bay Houses in Brooklyn, Hammel Houses in Queens and Mariner’s Harbor in Staten Island. During follow-up visits to these same sites, storeroom and managerial staff were unaware that any appliances were missing, telling DOI investigators that no appliances were missing from the storerooms, no thefts had occurred, or all appliance stock was accounted for. In one of these developments – the Sheepshead Bay Houses – a week after investigators removed a new stove from the premises, investigators observed that the storeroom remained open and unsecured, and the Assistant Superintendent reported that no appliances were missing or stolen.

  DOI also identified several other vulnerabilities at these NYCHA properties that need to be addressed to further secure appliances at developments, including the inadequate use of CCTV cameras to monitor employee areas like development storerooms, and a lack of routine physical inventory counts by managers to aid in the detection of theft or other losses.

  As a result of this follow up investigation, DOI determined that NYCHA failed to address the vulnerabilities identified in DOI’s 2016 theft investigation. As a result, DOI has made the following recommendations to NYCHA:

 Survey and improve security as needed at development storerooms and supply rooms, including installing self-closing and self-locking doors, alarm systems, electronic-layered access control systems, roll-down gates, and CCTV cameras. 

 Ensure that Housing Managers and Superintendents are practicing appropriate controls over storeroom and supply room keys such that only authorized NYCHA personnel – Housing Managers, Superintendents, Assistant Superintendents, Storeroom Keeper, Supervisor of Housing Caretakers, and Supervising Housing Groundskeeper – have key access. Development staff should be instructed to question unauthorized individuals found in development storerooms and to promptly report any suspicious activity to NYCHA’s Office of the Inspector General.

 Install signage at each storeroom indicating that access is restricted to authorized personnel. 

 Implement policy to track large appliances and other valuable items by manufacturer’s serial numbers via computerized systems, beginning at receipt from the supplier, through storage in storerooms/supply rooms, and following through to installation in individual resident’s apartments.  Enforce NYCHA policies requiring development managers to personally count 100% of all high-value (“Closed Kit”) inventory items each year, and to document and investigate any inventory imbalances.

DOI Commissioner Mark Peters thanks NYCHA Chair and Chief Executive Officer Shola Olatoye and her staff for their cooperation in this investigation.

  The investigation was conducted by DOI’s Office of the Inspector General for NYCHA, specifically Deputy Inspector General Osa Omoigui and Confidential Investigator Alfred Carletta, under the supervision of First Deputy Inspector General Pamela Sah, Inspector General Ralph Iannuzzi, Associate Commissioner James Flaherty, Deputy Commissioner/Chief of Investigations Michael Carroll and First Deputy Commissioner Lesley Brovner.