Tuesday, November 17, 2020



The City of New York filed a lawsuit today against landlords Gennaro Brooks-Church and Loretta Gendville, joint owners of 1214 Dean Street, a residential property in Brooklyn, as it takes steps to help tenants facing unlawful eviction. The lawsuit represents the Administration’s emphasis on enforcing the laws that protect tenants and is an example of how the City will not tolerate harassment during this unprecedented crisis.    


“This Administration will not tolerate landlords who illegally evict and harass tenants out of their homes, and we will take forceful action like today’s lawsuit to make that very clear,” said Ricardo Martínez Campos, Deputy Director for the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants.  “For landlords who think they can rely on these tactics and make them part of their business model, know that you are on notice, and we will not hesitate to bring you to Court.”   


“Our Office would like to thank the City’s Law Department for working closely with us to bring this case, as well as the tenants of 1214 Dean Street who recounted their difficult stories for us time and again. It is our hope that this case will have implications that reach beyond 1214 Dean Street and will make clear that tenants should be treated with dignity and respect, and that their rights under the law must be observed,” said Greta Aiken, Outreach and Engagement Coordinator for the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants. 


"Ensuring New Yorkers have a safe, quality home and protecting renters from harassment and illegal eviction is more important now than ever," said Deputy Mayor for Housing and Economic Development Vicki Been. “This action serves as a warning: If you violate tenants' rights, we will take action.”  


“Home should be where you feel you can put your head on your pillow and rest easy. In a time of pandemic, it should be the place you feel most safe”, said NYC Corporation Counsel James E. Johnson. “Today, we’re filing suit to ensure that safety and hold landlords accountable for their illegal and heartless acts. We have the tools to dismantle these egregious schemes and we will aggressively use them.”   


“Inflicting additional trauma onto those struggling to stay afloat during a pandemic by threatening eviction without process is not only immoral, but illegal," New York State Attorney General Letitia James said. "No one should fear having their home taken away at a time when their very life depends on social distancing and staying home; and no one should live in fear of reprisal from their landlord for asserting their lawful rights. Our investigation, working in tandem with the City’s lawsuit, will hold these landlords accountable for any illegal actions and will place other landlords on notice that they will be held accountable for unlawful eviction. "    


In July of this year, Brooks-Church and Gendville blatantly harassed the tenants of 1214 Dean Street, illegally evicting at least four tenants during the COVID-19 pandemic. The City’s Law Department responded with a Cease and Desist letter sent to the landlords on July 10th.     


Today, the Law Department, working with the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants (MOPT), sued Gendville and Brooks-Church. The City seeks civil penalties for violations of the NYC Unlawful Eviction Law, a finding of Tenant Harassment against defendants, correction of construction code violations that include unpermitted construction and illegal conversion, and civil penalties for those violations.   


By seeking civil penalties, the City seeks to reverse any windfall that landlords may receive from their bad acts, and to broadcast a message that other landlords think twice before illegally displacing tenants.     

The City is also working with the New York State Office of the Attorney General, who also have an active investigation into the actions of the Brooks-Church and Gendville. 


“In this time of extreme hardship, we’re going to be there for tenants and we’ve made it clear that tenant harassment will not fly under the radar of this Administration,” said HPD Commissioner Louise Carroll. “I thank all of our city and state partners for working together to hold landlords accountable and to protect New York City tenants in the middle of the pandemic, and every other day.” 


"Tenants deserve safe, legal housing, and should not be forced from their homes - not now, not ever, and certainly not during a pandemic," said DOB Commissioner Melanie La Rocca. "New Yorkers look out for their neighbors, and that's what we're doing here. We are proud to work alongside our partner agencies to protect the rights of tenants and help to build a fairer city for all." 


The City Unlawful Eviction Law affords the City the ability to advance tenants’ rights even where tenants themselves are unable or too intimidated to bring their own action before a Court. This lawsuit reaffirms City policy and values that no one should be removed from their home without required legal process.   

The 1214 Dean Street litigation is the result of sustained efforts by the current administration to strengthen tenant protection work across its agencies.   


Mayor Bill de Blasio created the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants (MOPT) in 2019 to coordinate the City’s range of tenant protection efforts. HPD expanded its tenant protection work with the establishment of its Anti-Harassment Unit in 2019, and the Law Department’s Affirmative Litigation Division assembled a special tenant protection team also in 2019.    


The Office of the Tenant Advocate was established at the Department of Buildings in 2017. DOB and HPD ensure buildings are safe and living conditions habitable, and together with the Law Department and MOPT, they work to counter illegal landlord harassment.    

No comments:

Post a Comment